Top 10 Welterweights from best to worst

[StarshipTrooper]

I'll start the show:

01. Ray Robinson
02. Sam Langford
03. Henry Armstrong
04. Ray Leonard
05. Kid Gavilan
06. Jose Napoles
07. Barney Ross
08. Jimmy McLarnin
09. Thomas Hearns
10. Emile Griffith


Bonus:

11. Oscar De La Hoya
12. Felix Trinidad
13. Antonio Cervantes
14. Wilfred Benitez
15. Shane Mosley
16. Duilio Loi
17. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
18. Tommy Ryan
19. Luis Rodriguez
20. Carmen Basilio
21. Aaron Pryor


Poet

[mickey malone]

1. Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Kid Gavilan
4. Ray Leonard
5. Jose Napoles
6. Thomas Hearns
7. Emile Griffith
8. Felix Trinidad
9. Jimmy McLarnin
10. Shane Mosley

[BigStereotype]

I'll start the show:

01. Ray Robinson
02. Sam Langford
03. Henry Armstrong
04. Ray Leonard
05. Kid Gavilan
06. Jose Napoles
07. Barney Ross
08. Jimmy McLarnin
09. Thomas Hearns
10. Emile Griffith


Bonus:

11. Oscar De La Hoya
12. Felix Trinidad
13. Antonio Cervantes
14. Wilfred Benitez
15. Shane Mosley
16. Duilio Loi
17. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
18. Tommy Ryan
19. Luis Rodriguez
20. Carmen Basilio
21. Aaron Pryor


Poet

Nice list. I think it's weird that you have Oscar ahead of Tito, Sugar Shane and Floyd, though. Other than that, it looks pretty solid.

[StarshipTrooper]

Nice list. I think it's weird that you have Oscar ahead of Tito, Sugar Shane and Floyd, though. Other than that, it looks pretty solid.

Well, in my view Oscar beat a prime Trinidad and got hosed on the cards. I also had him winning one of the Mosley fights and fighting Mayweather pretty damn close despite being over the hill. It's a judgement call I suppose but that's usually the case when dealing with fighters that are pretty close in talent.

Poet

[bklynboy]

Well, in my view Oscar beat a prime Trinidad and got hosed on the cards. I also had him winning one of the Mosley fights and fighting Mayweather pretty damn close despite being over the hill. It's a judgement call I suppose but that's usually the case when dealing with fighters that are pretty close in talent.

Poet

I liked Oscar until the Trinidad fight. When he coasted and gave away the last few rounds I wrote him off.

[sonnyboyx2]

Well, in my view Oscar beat a prime Trinidad and got hosed on the cards. I also had him winning one of the Mosley fights and fighting Mayweather pretty damn close despite being over the hill. It's a judgement call I suppose but that's usually the case when dealing with fighters that are pretty close in talent.

Poet

i am of the same opinion

[Del Coqui]

I think definitely Tito belongs in the top 10, holds record for title deffenses, took a lot of 0's while doing it.

[sonnyboyx2]

1/. Ray Robinson
2/. Henry Armstrong
3/. Sam Langford
4/. Ray Leonard
5/. Jose Napoles
6/. Pernell Whitaker
7/. Jack Britton
8/. Jimmy McLarnin
9/. Thomas Hearns
10/. Floyd Mayweather Jr.

[McGrain]

01 - Sugar Ray Robinson
02 - Jack Britton
03 - Kid Gavilan
04 - Sugar Ray Leoanrd
05 - Jose Napoles
06 - Emile Griffith
07 - Henry Armstrong
08 - Charley Burley
09 - Mickey Walker
10 - Joe Walcott
--------------------

11 - Luis Rodriguez
12 - Ted Kid Lewis
13 - Carmen Basilio
14 - Tommy Ryan
15 - Pernell Whitaker
16 - Thomas Hearns
17 - Jimmy McLarnin
18 - Oscar De La Hoya
19 - Sam Langford
20 - Joe Gans

[McGrain]

02. Sam Langford

What's the story here, buddy?

Same question to sonnyboy.