Who would win...

[SCtrojansbaby]

Hopkins and hagler have the same reach,plus Hagler beat plenty of bigger guys so your 'tremendous size advantage' point isnt really valid

Hagler gets his reach from his broad shoulders. Hopkins has much longer arms anybody can see that

[GJC]

A prime Marvin Hagler vs prime Bernard Hopkins.

I've watched both, their styles contrast but I think it would make for a great fight! They both have great achievements as middleweight champions, though at 2 different times. What would happen if they clashed?

Id favour Hagler but I'd point out that Hopkins is a very canny fighter I'd Hagler did struggle against the 2 canniest fighters he faced namely Duran and Leonard. Like I say I'd fancy Hagler but it might not be as easy as many would think

[The Surgeon]

I like Hagler on points in a fight that doesnt really explode into life