Were does Pacquaio rank among the ATG punchers?

[gatorDelux]

Do u guys think he is an atg puncher...

I would say he could be p4p any were form 50-15 on an atg punchers list....

ur guys thoughts...

[Perfect Plex]

For certain a ATG puncher, but he shound't rank in the top 15 or even 20.

[gatorDelux]

maybe around 30some?

an agument could be made for top 20...

but i think th most reasonable would be like 30

[Perfect Plex]

maybe around 30some?

an agument could be made for top 20...

but i think th most reasonable would be like 30

Well I can pretty easily name 20 harder punchers than him.

Louis, Langford, Ketchel, Saddler, Hearns, Jackson, Moore, Marciano, Wilde, Dempsey, Foreman, Shavers, Liston, Tyson, Robinson, Graziano, Baer, Foster, Fitzsimmons, & Zarate all P4P punched harder than him imo.

There's 20, and there quite a few more.

I'd say he's around the late 30, mid 40 range.

[SCtrojansbaby]

His left cross is probable the 3rd best single punch ever after Holmes Jab and Roy's left hook

[Perfect Plex]

His left cross is probable the 3rd best single punch ever after Holmes Jab and Roy's left hook

Robinson's left hook & Hearns's straight right>Pacquiao's left cross.

[gatorDelux]

His left cross is probable the 3rd best single punch ever after Holmes Jab and Roy's left hook

rjj doesnt have an all time great left hook IMO

[datum]

there are lot's of better puncher than him. I think if he would've stayed at the lighter weights, he would have a better case though.

[McGoorty]

Well I can pretty easily name 20 harder punchers than him.

Louis, Langford, Ketchel, Saddler, Hearns, Jackson, Moore, Marciano, Wilde, Dempsey, Foreman, Shavers, Liston, Tyson, Robinson, Graziano, Baer, Foster, Fitzsimmons, & Zarate all P4P punched harder than him imo.

There's 20, and there quite a few more.

I'd say he's around the late 30, mid 40 range.

I really don't know how you can be so adamant about that,.... How do you say that about a Flyweight who destroys WW's and even junior middles,,.. it's a lot more impressive than a HW knocking out a fellow HW, or am I Mad ????........ There is definately a case for Pacquiao in at least vthe top 20,... but really you can't compare littl'uns to bigguns,.... and there is a case for the LW division as the real all-time Deepest division,.... lets face it, there are 5 times as many ATG Lw's than HW's,.... put your top 50 up here ASAP, you may find the task impossible.

[SCtrojansbaby]

rjj doesnt have an all time great left hook IMO

I am convinced you have never watched a Roy Jones fight in your entire life